Episode intro (Lawrence Peryer): Hello and welcome to The Buzz, the podcast of the Jazz Journalists Association, an international professional organization of writers, photographers and broadcasters focused on jazz.
I am Lawrence Peryer, proud JJA member and managing editor of The Buzz.
This episode comes from the JJA archive. In 2010, Django Reinhardt's centennial year, the JJA was still presenting Jazz Matters, a series at The New School in New York. A panel titled Jazz Scholarship: The Next Generation opened with Paul Brady, who had written his master's thesis on Django. David Adler moderated, and Howard Mandel was among those asking questions. Paul spoke while the music world was in the thick of a Django revival, with festivals in cities across the country and hobbyists learning the solos note by note. He urged the press to spend less time on what he called "the romantic two-fingered Gypsy" and more on what Django played. Paul's case was that Django belongs in the line that leads to bebop, and he built his argument from chord tones, measures, and recordings.
Sixteen years on, much of what Paul argued has held up, and some of the conversation around Django has moved in directions he couldn't have seen at the time. I'll come back to that at the end. First, here's Paul Brady.
Paul Brady: If you Google famous Belgians, the first result is a webpage called famousbelgians.net. It's divided into categories and includes one for musicians. On the list is Jean-Baptiste "Django" Reinhardt, with the description "Inventor of the two-finger guitar-playing technique." It is true that Reinhardt did have a semi-dysfunctional left hand as a result of a fire.
But the last thing he should be remembered as is the inventor of the two-finger guitar-playing technique. This is not a project about Reinhardt's life, but a project that examines what it was about his guitar playing and improvising that has made him a canonical jazz figure. I will not emphasize his disability or ethnic background, because this has already been done in three recently published and well-researched books by the author Michael Dregni.
Dregni has embraced Reinhardt's Gypsy background and the currently huge group of Gypsy and non-Gypsy guitar players who honor the romantic and technical way that Reinhardt played. With few exceptions, these are not progressive jazz players, and they do little to move the music forward. This has caused Reinhardt to be known as a kind of Gypsy world folk music hybrid, when what he was known for in his lifetime was playing jazz guitar.
Reinhardt's improvising from around 1939 to his last recordings in 1953 is harmonically comparable to the bebop that has come to set the standard for what is today known as modern jazz. His vocabulary and technique have been absorbed by many in advantageous ways, but they have also been copied and regurgitated in performance to the point of improvisational plagiarism.
His solos from "Honeysuckle Rose," "I'll See You in My Dreams," and "Django's Tiger" are continuously performed note by note by many Reinhardt followers.
But what is more likely is that his technique and power came from having to be heard above the bal-musette accordion players that he accompanied in the dance halls of Paris. It's no mystery why Gunther Schuller, in his book The Swing Era: The Development of Jazz, 1930–1945, refers to the Rex Stewart-Django Reinhardt session as "amongst the priceless gems in the entire history of chamber jazz."
Schuller also wrote, in a footnote, "It would be fascinating to know whether Charlie Christian ever heard in his formative years the playing of Django Reinhardt, that extraordinary Belgian-born maverick who also developed early on an essentially melodic, linear, virtuoso style. This, however, came out of French-Spanish Gypsy folk traditions rather than any intrinsically American jazz styles, let alone blues."
Well, most of you know that session. Again, Gunther Schuller says that his style came out of French-Spanish Gypsy folk traditions rather than any intrinsically American jazz styles, let alone blues. On the contrary, jazz writer, historian, and head of the Institute of Jazz Studies at Rutgers University Dan Morgenstern had this to say about Reinhardt's playing when I made this comment to him.
I asked, "There is so much available to read about Reinhardt these days, and so much attention is focused on his Gypsy background. Everyone is enamored with the romanticism of his life, and for me, as a jazz enthusiast, I get tired of constantly reading about this romantic two-fingered Gypsy. I want to hear more about his improvising, more about his abilities."
Morgenstern responded, "You're absolutely right, because the Gypsy influence on Django's playing as a jazz artist is not that powerful. He may be ethnically a Gypsy playing jazz, but he was not a Gypsy musician. He could play Gypsy music, but even in most of his original compositions, there's very little trace of that."
It is odd to me that Schuller seems to think that Reinhardt's jazz phrasing came from a Gypsy folk tradition. Reinhardt's playing was totally steeped in American swing, deeply rooted in the blues, and it's easy to hear that in the sessions with Stewart.
Besides the common misconception that Reinhardt's jazz style developed from Gypsy folk traditions, there's another myth that needs correcting. Oftentimes, people will ask about his having been influenced by the guitar-violin duo of Eddie Lang and Joe Venuti. A recent entry published in the Encyclopedia of Jazz Musicians at jazz.com by the writer Donald James said this: "Reinhardt's best work was done with violinist Stéphane Grappelli and the group they founded, the Quintet of the Hot Club of France, which was originally inspired by Americans Eddie Lang and Joe Venuti.
"The Hot Club quickly developed its own sound, drawn from Django's Gypsy roots, and his jazz manouche became enormously influential on both sides of the Atlantic." If you read the most recent biography of Reinhardt, by Dregni, you'll discover an interview with Stéphane Grappelli, who said that he, Grappelli, had been wowed by Venuti when he saw him at L'Ambassadeur in 1928, and Django may have been influenced by the recordings of Lang's single-string playing.
But the quintet sought to play true jazz with hot improvisation. Asked what he thought of Lang, Django was succinct: "Very limited." Stéphane further recalled Django saying simply that there was nothing to be learned from Lang. To comment on James's suggestion that it was Reinhardt's Gypsy roots that developed the Quintet of the Hot Club of France's sound, let's examine what Dregni's research presents on Reinhardt's development.
"When Django was at his zenith in the 1930s and 1940s, no one termed the music he played Gypsy jazz. It was simply jazz played by a Gypsy with a guitar. He learned the music primarily from recordings and only later by playing with many of the early greats: Louis Armstrong, Coleman Hawkins, Duke Ellington, Eddie South.
"And with the music from those foreign 78s still reverberating in his ears, he was trying to sound as American as he possibly could. Combining his influences, his pioneering use of the guitar, and his individual sensibility, Django created a music of his own. There are few others who single-handedly gave birth to a whole musical genre, and it's a genre that is today continually re-created."
It's true that this genre of music inspired by Django Reinhardt is being continually re-created. Nearly every major city in the US, and some smaller ones now too, has a Django Reinhardt or Gypsy jazz festival. And there are more musicians performing Django Reinhardt-inspired music than ever before. As wonderful as this is, "Gypsy jazz" remains a misleading term and a marketing ploy to sell books and records and to promote artists and their concerts.
As a member of the jazz group the Hot Club of Detroit, with three recordings on the Mack Avenue label, I am a living product of such trends. And as suggested, I strongly dislike the notion that Gypsy jazz is a distinct jazz guitar subgenre. It artificially separates the music created by Reinhardt, and now inspired by him, from all other forms of jazz.
With this subgenre continuing to increase in popularity, many people are taking up guitar and other instruments, inspired to play like Reinhardt. The majority of the hobbyists and many of the professionals whom I've encountered have been seduced by the term "Gypsy jazz." Even some of the best and most well-known young professional players of this genre have succumbed to being categorized as Gypsy jazz guitarists.
The enthusiasm generated by this resurgence has been an overwhelmingly positive phenomenon to witness. As such, it is with some regret that I express my dissatisfaction concerning both the routine misapplications of the term "Gypsy jazz," and the confusion that has resulted from it, and the literature that emphasizes Reinhardt's personal eccentricities and Gypsy ethnicity.
My encounters have shown me that the majority of the hobbyists do not understand that Reinhardt was, in the truest sense, a jazz guitarist. Although they approach learning his music with great discipline, the end result usually produces a musician with adequate guitar technique and a few highly derivative Reinhardt licks, but little concept of correct jazz harmony or phrasing.
In some, what is produced is a sound that is not very reminiscent of Reinhardt at all. I'd like to discuss Reinhardt's bebop improvising. "Django's Tiger" is a song composed by Reinhardt over the chord changes to the improvised section of "Tiger Rag." The session took place in January 1946 in London.
During the first chorus of this, Reinhardt presents a very controlled improvisation. He often lands on the third and ninth chord degrees on the downbeats of the chord changes, explicitly defining the harmonic resolutions, as opposed to diatonically glossing over the harmony, which was characteristic of the swing-era improvisers.
What is in fact present here is bebop improvising. The reason this is interesting is because, as documented in Dregni's biography of Reinhardt, he was not exposed to Dizzy Gillespie's first record as a leader, which included Parker on alto sax and is often considered the first bebop record, until later that year, in 1946.
So Reinhardt essentially had the linear style that has become associated with bebop before his first exposure to Gillespie and Parker.
"Where is Dizzy Gillespie?" is supposedly what Reinhardt said when he arrived in America for a tour with the Duke Ellington Orchestra in October 1946. Reinhardt's first bebop composition was "Babik (Bebop)," written in 1947. The primary melodic riff of "Babik" is laid out in antecedent and consequent phrases over F major rhythm changes.
Its thematic repetition is very similar to Gillespie's composing. So infatuated was Reinhardt with Gillespie that his bridge is a blatant rhythmical quote of Gillespie's "Salt Peanuts."
Surprisingly, Django's bebop solos have more space than his earlier solos. He approaches the A sections of rhythm-changes tunes with more rhythmic and harmonic freedom, emphasizing blue notes and sidestepping. The rhythm-changes bridge contains more traditional bebop material. We hear fluid eighth-note lines and more quotations of "Salt Peanuts."
Additionally, on the playful B-flat rhythm-changes head "Moppin' the Bride," a variation on what has become known as "Here Comes the Bride," by Richard Wagner, from his opera Lohengrin, we find a Gillespie influence. On the second beat of measure six, the melody goes from an E to a D-flat over a G7 chord, demonstrating phrasing from the thirteenth chord tone to the flat fifth.
The same phrase occurs again, transposed down a second, in measure nine of the bridge. The use of the thirteenth and flat-fifth scale degrees can be found in many of the beboppers' improvisations and is present in the bridge of the Gillespie/Parker composition "Shaw 'Nuff."
"Moppin' the Bride."
"Shaw 'Nuff," so you can hear the thirteenth to the flat five over the bridge.
Reinhardt's solo on "Moppin' the Bride" is again characteristic of his bebop style. The first two A sections of his second chorus present us with blue notes, lots of space, quarter notes, and quarter-note triplets similar to those in "Babik." The bridge, again, is where we see the fluid bebop eighth notes.
He plays an almost identical phrase from "Django's Tiger," as described previously, but this time with continuous eighth notes.
The take of Michael Dregni, the author of the most recent biography, on Reinhardt's approach to bebop is different from my own. Dregni says, "Django's guitar spoke the syntax of bebop, but his was not the same bebop as Dizzy and Bird. Theirs was horn music, his guitar. He could play their notes, but he had to create his own language."
The jazz language transcends instrumentation, especially bebop, and much of what Reinhardt played earlier in his career can be found in the improvisations of Louis Armstrong. So, in fact, there is horn music in Reinhardt's spontaneous playing. When you look closely again at the second chorus of his solo on "Moppin' the Bride," we find that he uses the third of the G7 chord and resolves it a half step down to the seventh of the C7 chord, exactly the sort of bebop voice leading that Parker would use. What we have is a larger-than-life player with such a monstrous musical personality, ahead of its time, that there was no reason and no possibility for Reinhardt to need to sound like Gillespie or Parker.
What is more, it is possible that Reinhardt had an influence on bebop. Jazz historian Lewis Porter writes in his book Jazz: From Its Origins to the Present, "It is certain that the beboppers were aware of Reinhardt. Perhaps the boppers even borrowed the idea of '-ology' titles ('Anthropology,' 'Ornithology,' 'Crazeology') from Reinhardt's 1935 'Djangology.'"
For Reinhardt, bebop was not as new a harmonic style as it may have been for others, but it gave him new compositional ideas and more freedom to be the harmonic and rhythmic genius that he was. Recently, there's been a renewed interest in the style of Reinhardt's playing. His music has been popular amongst jazz listeners ever since his lifetime, but in roughly the last ten years, there's been an increase in interest in it.
Several major cities in the United States now have annual Django Reinhardt festivals: New York, which began in 2000; Los Angeles; San Francisco; Chicago; Detroit; Colorado; and the largest one, DjangoFest Northwest in Washington State, which began in 2001. What we can see is that all these festivals began after the release of what's probably been the biggest contributor to the renewed interest in Reinhardt: Woody Allen's 1999 film Sweet and Lowdown, about a fictional jazz guitarist named Emmet Ray who's obsessed with the music of Django Reinhardt.
Currently, the interest continues to grow, and we can expect more Reinhardt madness, as we are now in his centennial year. Although there are jazz musicians popping up all over the world who are deeply indebted to Reinhardt's style, I'd like to mention specifically the music of two modern jazz improvisers who pay tribute to Reinhardt through their own voices.
The French Gypsy Biréli Lagrène recorded his first album, Routes to Django, at age thirteen. But by fifteen, Lagrène was stuck. There was no opportunity for him to grow within this music. Gypsy jazz, as prescribed by his Gypsy elders, ironically lacked freedom of expression for him. Lagrène would eventually tour in groups alongside John McLaughlin, Al Di Meola, Larry Coryell, Vic Juris, Stanley Clarke, the Gil Evans Orchestra, Stanley Jordan, Danilo Pérez, and Charlie Haden.
And in 1986, Lagrène would record for the first time with electric bassist Jaco Pastorius. Lagrène's amazing experiences have contributed to what is possibly the freshest take on Reinhardt-style playing. He is now back performing in various groups modeled after Reinhardt's, with a voice that is truly his own.
Larry Coryell said of Lagrène in a recent "Before & After" listening quiz for JazzTimes magazine, "Biréli Lagrène. He and I had a terrible falling out, and we haven't spoken for ten years. I know every note he's ever played. He's probably the best in the world, and he can imitate anybody on the guitar, or on the bass, or singing."
This is Lagrène's recording of "Coquette," in one of his more traditional Django-sounding groups.
This next one is something from his most recent record, which is a lot more modern and electronic and very much influenced by Jaco Pastorius, Weather Report, and the fusion that Biréli Lagrène went on to play.
"Incertitude." It's by Babik Reinhardt, the son of Django Reinhardt.
Finally, perhaps the most interesting musician to be honoring the Reinhardt style today is not a guitarist at all, but a saxophonist, James Carter. One aspect of Carter's ability that makes him such a great fit for Reinhardt-style playing is that he's able to emulate guitar techniques on the saxophone, likely something that attracted him to the style in the first place.
These extended techniques opened a totally new arena for him to explore through his instrument, over which he has so much control and ability. Conventional saxophone playing has never been something he dwells on very long during his improvisations. What is so frightening about Carter's playing is his time and his power to make you feel his notes in the back of your throat.
I find this especially interesting because it was Reinhardt's time that Coleman Hawkins admired so much that he specifically mentioned it to Dan Morgenstern. James Carter's 2000 Chasin' the Gypsy, on Atlantic, features mostly Reinhardt-style repertoire in a somewhat traditional instrumentation. His two most recent recordings, Present Tense, from 2008, and Heaven on Earth, live at the Blue Note, from 2009, include the Reinhardt compositions "Pour que ma vie demeure" and "Diminishing."
I'll play you an example of "Diminishing" by Django Reinhardt, and then Carter's.
It is clear that Django Reinhardt will forever be remembered as an innovative genius in multiple musical circles. It remains unclear why people associated with this genre resist the jazz label. Maybe that is what is so great about Django Reinhardt: that he transcends categorization. Perhaps celebrated classical guitarist Julian Bream summed it up best.
He said of his initial attraction to the guitar, in the 2003 documentary Julian Bream: My Life in Music, "My father had a number of very good jazz records, but the music that really interested me and enthused me was the Hot Club of France, with Stéphane Grappelli and Django Reinhardt. It was Reinhardt's guitar playing that so stimulated me musically that I was drawn to the guitar like a magnet.
"I felt his playing was so evocative, so powerful at times, so dramatic, and at other times so lyrical, that he seemed to hold within his musical grasp the whole gamut of human expression." Thank you.
David Adler: Any quick, very specific questions about that? Howard?
Howard Mandel: Who played clarinet on the Django piece you demonstrated early on?
Paul: On "Babik"? I think it was Hubert Rostaing.
Howard: Who played the parts in the Woody Allen movie? Not the Django part.
Paul: Ken Peplowski. And Howard Alden.
Howard: No, Howard Alden.
Paul: Oh, the guitar part. Yes. Howard Alden.
Howard: And has he benefited from the Django...
Paul: In fact, I was just with Howard last night, and it's something we talk about a lot. I did ask him that, and he said prior to the movie he definitely did not have as much work in those circles. And since then, it's blown up for him.
Howard: One other question. Did Django hear Monk?
Paul: That I don't know. I suppose it's possible when he was in New York, but it's not documented in any of the biographies that I've read, and it hasn't been told to me by anyone.
Howard: The last sample you played, is that one of his later compositions?
Paul: "Diminishing"? No. In fact, it was recorded with the original Hot Club of France, with Grappelli, so it would have been in the '40s at the latest.
Howard: Thank you.
David: Anyone else? Questions?
Audience member: Do you know who was on James Carter's recording?
Paul: Yeah. The guitarist is Adam Rogers, the bass player is Christian McBride, Joey Baron is the drummer, and John Medeski is on organ.
Audience member: Couldn't get any better.
David: I have a quick question.
Paul: Sure.
David: Remind me the name of that last Biréli record, the electric one.
Paul: It's called Electric Side.
David: And you mentioned James Carter using guitaristic techniques. I wonder if you could just pinpoint that for a second.
Paul: Sure.
David: Concretely.
Paul: He will play Reinhardt licks that you wouldn't think could be played on an instrument other than the guitar. Django does all these tremolo things with his right hand, and James is able to really emulate that. On a guitar, you can play an open string and then that same note on another string to get the effect of two strings sounding simultaneously. Django would do that with a tremolo picking style, and James has been able to emulate that on his horn.
He uses another technique called slap-tonguing, which kind of sounds like when you play a harmonic on the guitar. And Django would sometimes play entire solos using artificial harmonics, so James will do that as well.
Howard: Also, he fans. The way he does that.
Paul: Yeah, like waving the keys around.
David: Any other questions on Django? And then we're going to move on.
Paul: Okay.
Episode outro (Lawrence): Much of what Paul asked for in that room has come to pass. Around the time of his talk, Benjamin Givan published The Music of Django Reinhardt, a book-length analysis of his improvising and the technique behind it.
Paul set Django's injury aside to keep attention on the playing. Researchers since then have treated the hand as central to the style. A 2014 study used motion tracking on old film footage to measure how Django spread and angled his index and middle fingers to make up for the two that were burned. George McKay, writing on jazz and disability, describes guitarists with full use of their hands who fret with only two digits out of reverence, trying to get closer to Django's sound. Paul keeps watch on this. In 2025 he posted on Instagram that it was "pretty shocking" to find Django's left hand still misunderstood in a New York Times piece.
Paul wanted Django heard as a jazz musician first, and he largely is, though the discussion of identity has gone somewhere Paul didn't take it. Paul uses the word Gypsy throughout, as almost anyone would have in 2010. The ethnomusicologist Siv Lie treats it as a name outsiders gave Romanies, one that some reclaim and others reject. Her 2021 book, Django Generations, follows Manouche musicians in France, Django's own community, who carry this music in their families now. Some of them lean into Gypsy imagery for one audience and push back on it for another. In some quarters, at the time of this writing, the word is an unusable ethnic slur.
Paul's main point holds. The way writers frame an artist shapes what listeners hear. In 2010 that meant looking past the legend to the notes. Today it also means getting his people's story right.
Thank you Paul Brady, David Adler, and Howard Mandel.
Don't miss new episodes of The Buzz. Make sure you follow us wherever you listen to podcasts.
For more from the Jazz Journalists Association, go to JJANews.org.
I am Lawrence Peryer, thanks for listening.